|July 30, 2012|
Previously published on July 23, 2012
In prior Trusts & Estates Newsletters, we alerted you to the changes to the federal and Connecticut estate, gift and generation-skipping transfer taxes that resulted from legislative action at the end of 2010 and in 2011. Among those changes was an increase in the amount that each person may give away free of federal gift tax in 2012 to $5.12 million. That exemption amount is slated to expire at the end of 2012 and, if Congress takes no action, will revert to $1 million in 2013.
This increased exemption may provide certain clients with a unique opportunity to make significant lifetime gifts prior to year-end. However, while there has been much discussion of this "opportunity" in the press, there are many factors that impact whether making such gifts this year makes sense. Therefore, we thought it would be helpful to summarize some of the considerations that are part of that analysis and highlight some of the potential drawbacks of such gifts.
The primary consideration in determining whether to make gifts in 2012 to take advantage of the $5.12 million gift tax exemption is your comfort level. Put simply, not all clients will be comfortable with the idea of giving away such large sums because they are concerned they will need those funds during their lifetimes. However, if you are married, we can assist you in creating a gifting strategy that will allow you and your spouse to use all or a portion of the current $5.12 million gift tax exemption while still having access to the gifted property if needed during your lifetimes. If you are not married, there may be other ways to benefit from the gifted property. Such planning is somewhat complex and is not free of risk, and therefore not all clients may want to engage in it.
There are other potential drawbacks to making gifts in 2012 to take advantage of some or all of the present $5.12 million gift tax exemption. First and perhaps most important, property given away during life does not receive a step-up in basis at the donor’s death. This may make 2012 gifts less appealing for those clients who would be using low basis assets for the gifts. In fact, it may take a number of years of appreciation of the gifted assets for the estate tax benefits of the gift to outweigh the capital gains cost of the gift if it were later to be sold by the recipient. The loss of the step-up in basis would be particularly unfortunate for clients who decided to make gifts now only to find that the gift tax exemption is not significantly reduced in 2013 and beyond.
In addition to the loss of step-up in basis for gifted property, Connecticut residents have a unique consideration in deciding whether to make gifts to use the $5.12 million federal gift tax exemption. Unlike other states, Connecticut imposes its own gift tax, against which each individual has a $2 million exemption. A $5.12 million gift over and above $13,000 annual exclusion gifts would create a Connecticut gift tax liability of approximately $240,000. However, gifts of out-of-state real property are not subject to the Connecticut gift tax. Accordingly, the Connecticut gift tax must be considered as part of the gifting
analysis. Finally, there is the possibility that if the $5.12 million gift tax exemption rolls back to $1 million at the end of 2012, the benefit of the expanded exemption amount might roll back as well, and the difference between the two exemption amounts might be includible in the donor’s estate at death. This possibility is referred to among practitioners as the "clawback." Commentators have generally downplayed the possibility of the "clawback" taking effect, but until the legislative dust settles this possibility cannot be dismissed completely.
It is important to look beyond the headlines and not assume that gifts to use the $5.12 million federal gift tax exemption are appropriate for all situations. While taking advantage of the 2012 opportunity may be suitable in some circumstances, each client must weigh all of the relevant factors to determine whether to proceed with taxable gifts in 2012. Clients interested in making such gifts should contact their attorney in the Trusts & Estates Practice Group to determine whether such gifting is appropriate for their particular situation.