Natalie C. Schaefer

Natalie C. Schaefer: Attorney with Shuman, McCuskey & Slicer, PLLC
  • Member at Shuman, McCuskey & Slicer, PLLC (25 Attorneys)
  • The Virginia Center, 1411 Virginia Street, E., Suite 200, P.O. Box 3953, Charleston, WV 25339
    View Natalie C. Schaefer's office location
  • Ms. Schaefer practices civil litigation defense in the areas of insurance law, governmental entity defense, and construction law.
  • Peer Reviews
    4.5/5.0 (25)
    Client Reviews
    No Reviews
  • Profile Visibility [ i ]

Natalie C. Schaefer's Peer Reviews

  • 4.5/5.0 (25)
  • A Martindale-Hubbell Peer Rating reflects a combination of achieving a Very High General Ethical Standards rating and a Legal Ability numerical rating.
  • Legal Knowledge

    4.5/5.0
  • Analytical Capability

    4.6/5.0
  • Judgment

    4.5/5.0
  • Communication

    4.6/5.0
  • Legal Experience

    4.3/5.0

‹ Back to Attorney Profile     ‹ Back to Firm Profile  

  • Natalie C. Schaefer

    5.0/5.0 by a Member on 10/16/13 in Civil Litigation

    Natalie is a superb lawyer who has demonstrated skills and abilities beyond her years. She practices in a manner where her ethical approach is above question.

    Read more

    Natalie is a superb lawyer who has demonstrated skills and abilities beyond her years. She practices in a manner where her ethical approach is above question.

    • Legal Knowledge

      5.0/5.0
    • Analytical Capability

      5.0/5.0
    • Judgment

      5.0/5.0
    • Communication

      5.0/5.0
    • Legal Experience

      5.0/5.0
    Read less
  • Natalie C. Schaefer

    4.8/5.0 by a Partner on 10/16/13 in Civil Litigation

    Natalie is tough, smart and pragmatic. She does an excellent job walking that fine line between advocacy and obstinance.

    Read more

    Natalie is tough, smart and pragmatic. She does an excellent job walking that fine line between advocacy and obstinance.

    • Legal Knowledge

      5.0/5.0
    • Analytical Capability

      5.0/5.0
    • Judgment

      4.0/5.0
    • Communication

      5.0/5.0
    • Legal Experience

      5.0/5.0
    Read less
  • Natalie C. Schaefer

    5.0/5.0 by a Associate on 11/05/13 in Premises Liability Defense

    • Legal Knowledge

      5.0/5.0
    • Analytical Capability

      5.0/5.0
    • Judgment

      5.0/5.0
    • Communication

      5.0/5.0
    • Legal Experience

      5.0/5.0
    Read less
  • Natalie C. Schaefer

    5.0/5.0 by a Sole Practitioner on 11/01/13 in Defense Litigation

    • Legal Knowledge

      5.0/5.0
    • Analytical Capability

      5.0/5.0
    • Judgment

      5.0/5.0
    • Communication

      5.0/5.0
    • Legal Experience

      5.0/5.0
    Read less
  • Natalie C. Schaefer

    5.0/5.0 by a Associate on 10/16/13 in Civil Litigation

    • Legal Knowledge

      5.0/5.0
    • Analytical Capability

      5.0/5.0
    • Judgment

      5.0/5.0
    • Communication

      5.0/5.0
    • Legal Experience

      5.0/5.0
    Read less
  • Natalie C. Schaefer

    5.0/5.0 by a Associate/Assistant General Counsel on 10/16/13 in Automobile Liability Defense

    • Legal Knowledge

      5.0/5.0
    • Analytical Capability

      5.0/5.0
    • Judgment

      5.0/5.0
    • Communication

      5.0/5.0
    • Legal Experience

      5.0/5.0
    Read less
  • Natalie C. Schaefer

    5.0/5.0 by a Associate/Assistant General Counsel on 10/16/13 in Medical Malpractice Defense

    • Legal Knowledge

      5.0/5.0
    • Analytical Capability

      5.0/5.0
    • Judgment

      5.0/5.0
    • Communication

      5.0/5.0
    • Legal Experience

      5.0/5.0
    Read less
  • Natalie C. Schaefer

    5.0/5.0 by a Associate/Assistant General Counsel on 10/16/13 in Wrongful Death

    • Legal Knowledge

      5.0/5.0
    • Analytical Capability

      5.0/5.0
    • Judgment

      5.0/5.0
    • Communication

      5.0/5.0
    • Legal Experience

      5.0/5.0
    Read less
  • Natalie C. Schaefer

    5.0/5.0 by a Associate/Assistant General Counsel on 10/16/13 in Insurance Litigation

    • Legal Knowledge

      5.0/5.0
    • Analytical Capability

      5.0/5.0
    • Judgment

      5.0/5.0
    • Communication

      5.0/5.0
    • Legal Experience

      5.0/5.0
    Read less
  • Natalie C. Schaefer

    5.0/5.0 by a Associate/Assistant General Counsel on 10/16/13 in Litigation

    • Legal Knowledge

      5.0/5.0
    • Analytical Capability

      5.0/5.0
    • Judgment

      5.0/5.0
    • Communication

      5.0/5.0
    • Legal Experience

      5.0/5.0
    Read less

*Peer Reviews provided before April 15, 2008 are not displayed.

Contact Natalie C. Schaefer

Please correct the fields highlighted in red.

By clicking on the "Submit" button, you agree to the Terms of Use, Supplemental Terms and Privacy Policy. You also consent to be contacted at the phone number you provided, including by autodials, text messages and/or pre-recorded calls, from Martindale and its affiliates and from or on behalf of attorneys you request or contact through this site. Consent is not a condition of purchase.


You should not send any sensitive or confidential information through this site. Emails sent through this site do not create an attorney-client relationship and may not be treated as privileged or confidential. The lawyer or law firm you are contacting is not required to, and may choose not to, accept you as a client. The Internet is not necessarily secure and emails sent though this site could be intercepted or read by third parties.