Charles J. Smith

Charles J. Smith: Attorney with Law Offices of Charles J. Smith III

Biography

Charles J. Smith has been one of the leading trial lawyers in the San Francisco Bay Area since the late 1970’s to present. Mr. Smith began his career with the San Mateo County District Attorney’s office in 1978. In 1980 he was elevated to the Major Crimes Unit where he tried 15 homicides. He then practiced insurance defense as an Associate with Ropers, Majeski, Kohn, Bentley, Wagner and Kane, where he tried and won five civil jury trials in a fourteen month period. Mr. Smith began his own practice in 1991. He tries from five to ten cases a year in both the civil and criminal courts of this state. Mr. Smith has tried jury trials from Crescent City in Del Norte County in the north to Indio in San Bernardino County in the south achieving victory after victory on behalf of his clients. Mr. Smith has tried cases as varied as the defense of Silicon Valley venture capitalists being sued for $20,000,000 on a fraud claim to defending a former U.S. Army Captain who was acquitted of mandatory prison charges based on a PTSD defense. Mr. Smith enjoys the variety of cases that he has taken to trial. As in the British system of solicitors and barristers, Mr. Smith believes that a trial lawyer should be able to try any dispute where a question of credibility exists. His qualities of hard work, thorough preparation, intense energy and devotion to his client’s cause are the hallmark of his trial practice.

Mr. Smith was elected to the American Board of Trial Advocates in 1992. Over the course of his career, he has tried over 300 jury trials to verdict. In 2003 alone, he tried 14 jury trials to verdict-seven civil trials and seven criminal trials-more than any other private lawyer in the state of California.

In 2009, the 32nd year of his practice Mr. Smith tried six cases to verdict including the successful defense of a local community college against an employment claim in Monterey County and obtaining an acquittal for a fellow lawyer who was charged with felony assault over an alleged ‘road rage’ incident in San Mateo County.

In 2015, Mr. Smith’s 40th year of practice, he has tried ten cases. Seven of these went to either jury verdict or court decision. Among the most notable, Mr. Smith successfully defended a high-level engineer at Apple Computer who was charged with gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated in the Santa Clara County Superior Court. He was acquitted. In a trial in May 2015 before Hon. Barbara Mallach in Redwood City, Mr. Smith obtained a decision for a gasoline wholesaler against a service station owner which included every dollar of damages and every dollar of attorney’s fees.

Between August 3, 2015 and December 16, 2015, Mr. Smith commenced seven jury trials, four of which went to verdict. Four of these cases were criminal and three civil. Like a baseball pitcher who stays sharp and focused by starting every four days, Mr. Smith likewise believes that regularly trying cases at the pace of approximately once per month hones his skills and keeps him at the top of his game.

Mr. Smith has been invited to provide his expert legal commentary for both the Bay Area and national press. He has appeared as a legal analyst on CNN, CBS, Larry King Live, and Good Morning America. Mr. Smith speaks to lawyers groups on trial practice and volunteers his time to the local high school community as a teacher/coach in the statewide Mock Trial Program.

Mr. Smith has received an AV rating from Martindale Hubbell, the national directory of lawyers. This is the highest possible rating attainable and indicates preeminent legal ability and the utmost ethical standards.

Areas of Practice (18)

  • Civil Litigation
  • Criminal Defense
  • Criminal Law
  • DUI/DWI
  • Traffic Violations
  • Drugs and Narcotics
  • Misdemeanors
  • Felonies
  • White Collar Crime
  • Real Estate
  • Land Sales
  • Contracts
  • Business Law
  • Probate
  • Wills
  • Trusts and Estates
  • Labor and Employment
  • Litigation

Education & Credentials

Contact Information:
650-249-6835  Phone
650-568-2823  Fax
www.hartnettsmith.com
University Attended:
Lehigh University, B.A., 1973
Law School Attended:
Santa Clara University, J.D., 1976
Year of First admission:
1976
Admission:
1976, California and U.S. District Court, Northern District of California
Memberships:
San Mateo County and Santa Clara County Bar Associations; State Bar of California; American Board of Trial Advocates (Association).
Birth Information:
Elgin, Illinois, October 22, 1951
Reported Cases:

Randall v. Campbell, Santa Clara County, CV804209, Jan. 2003 defense of breach of contract and fraud claims, defense verdict.

Dennis Carroll v. Lorraine Andel, San Mateo County CIV418215, July 2003, defense of wrongful death claim, defense verdict.

Balce v. Lucky Chances, Inc. USDC, Northern District; 07-01090 Hon. Jeffrey White, Feb 2008, defense of wage and hour claims, defense verdict.

Lawrence/Culver v. Hartnell Community College, Monterey County, M88730, July 2009, successful defense of a $2 million wrongful termination claim by two executive assistants. Defense verdict on all claims.;

Moncayo v. Holiday Inn, San Mateo County, CIV478734, June 2010, defense of wage and hour claims, discrimination in workplace claims, defense verdict.;

Specialized v. Volagi, Santa Clara County 1-10-CV185692, Jan. 2012, breach of contract, theft of trade secrets, defense, recovery of client’s attorney’s fees.

Mary Lucas v. Recommind, San Francisco County; CGC 10-497516, July 2012, defense of wrongful termination, wage and hour; defense verdict.

People v. D.B., Santa Clara County Superior Court, Palo Alto Division, April 2014, acquittal of a Seattle Seahawks wide receiver charged with unlawful battery.

Arturo Salume v. Myrta Salume, San Mateo County, June 2014, defense of breach of contract claims, defense verdict.

Stevens v. Davis, San Mateo Superior Case #CIV524878, June 2015, Hon. Richard DuBois, defense decision in a wrongful termination claim by an African-American caregiver against the family that employed her.

Lopez et. al. v. Lucky Chances, San Mateo County, Hon. Joseph Bergeron, April 2015: defense of a $5million class action tip-pooling wage and hour claim.

DFEH v. Fortune Players Group, San Mateo County, Judge Elizabeth Lee, Sept. 2015 defense of wrongful failure to promote based on gender/ethnic origin, $200,000 settlement demand, $35,000 verdict.

People v. Marcos H. – Santa Clara County, Judge JoAnne McCracken, October 2016, hung 9-3 for acquittal in child pornography charges, case dismissed.

People v. Wayne Bair – San Mateo County, Judge Lisa Novak, Nov./Dec. 2016 – acquittal of 1 st Degree Murder charges – first outright acquittal in a 1st Degree Murder charge in San Mateo County since mid-90’s.

People v. Sam K. – Santa Clara County, Judge Shelyna Brown – April 2017 – acquittal of 7 counts of lewd conduct with a child.

ISLN:
903634074

Peer Reviews

  • 5.0/5.0
  • A Martindale-Hubbell Peer Rating reflects a combination of achieving a Very High General Ethical Standards rating and a Legal Ability numerical rating.

*Peer Reviews provided before April 15, 2008 are not displayed.

Client Reviews

  • 1.8/5.0 (4)
  • 1 recommendation
  • Communication

    2.5/5.0
  • Responsiveness

    1.5/5.0
  • Quality of Service

    1.8/5.0
  • Value for Money

    1.5/5.0
  • Charles J. Smith

    3.0/5.0 on 05/07/10 on 05/07/10

    Read more

    • Communication

      3.0/5.0
    • Responsiveness

      3.0/5.0
    • Quality of Service

      3.0/5.0
    • Value for Money

      3.0/5.0
    Read less
  • Charles J. Smith

    2.0/5.0 on 06/07/11 on 06/07/11

    Chuck Smith is an excellent attorney when he wants to be. He is a very good in-trial attorney provided the investigation has been done well enough for him. Unfortunately...

    Read more

    Chuck Smith is an excellent attorney when he wants to be. He is a very good in-trial attorney provided the investigation has been done well enough for him. Unfortunately for me, Chuck overbooked his trial schedule with wealthier clients, misjudged the competency of the local DA, and was not properly prepared for the defense of my case. After paying him over $100,000 I had to fire him and hire a new attorney. When he can't sell the DA or the jury, he'll sell you on empty promises and bad advice.

    • Communication

      5.0/5.0
    • Responsiveness

      1.0/5.0
    • Quality of Service

      1.0/5.0
    • Value for Money

      1.0/5.0
    Read less
  • Charles J. Smith

    1.3/5.0 on 04/20/12 on 04/20/12

    Chuck sold me on a resolution that he did not fully understand himself. He placed me in a vulnerable position. He took the easy way out instead of looking deeper into m...

    Read more

    Chuck sold me on a resolution that he did not fully understand himself. He placed me in a vulnerable position. He took the easy way out instead of looking deeper into my case.

    • Communication

      1.0/5.0
    • Responsiveness

      1.0/5.0
    • Quality of Service

      2.0/5.0
    • Value for Money

      1.0/5.0
    Read less
  • Charles J. Smith

    1.0/5.0 on 02/04/17 on 02/04/17

    Unfortunately Charles J. Smith lost both hearings due to failure to properly analyze or defend my cases. He failed at the appellate level by insufficient and untimely fil...

    Read more

    Unfortunately Charles J. Smith lost both hearings due to failure to properly analyze or defend my cases. He failed at the appellate level by insufficient and untimely filing yet billed me attorney fees for the preparation of the appellate case. He refused to refund me any of he fees even though his insufficient and untimely preparation was the cause of the appelllate dismissal. He is unresponsive and an extrememly poor communicator and NEVER informed me if the outcome of my case, etc.

    • Communication

      1.0/5.0
    • Responsiveness

      1.0/5.0
    • Quality of Service

      1.0/5.0
    • Value for Money

      1.0/5.0
    Read less

See All 4 Reviews

Disclaimer

Documents ({{amountArticles}})

Documents by this lawyer on Martindale.com
Other documents: ,

Redwood City, California

Contact Charles J. Smith

Please correct the fields highlighted in red.

By clicking on the "Submit" button, you agree to the Terms of Use, Supplemental Terms and Privacy Policy. You also consent to be contacted at the phone number you provided, including by autodials, text messages and/or pre-recorded calls, from Martindale and its affiliates and from or on behalf of attorneys you request or contact through this site. Consent is not a condition of purchase.


You should not send any sensitive or confidential information through this site. Emails sent through this site do not create an attorney-client relationship and may not be treated as privileged or confidential. The lawyer or law firm you are contacting is not required to, and may choose not to, accept you as a client. The Internet is not necessarily secure and emails sent though this site could be intercepted or read by third parties.